Monday, 16 November 2026

Overthinking it: on the Limitations of Research; or, crashing the gate

 


Crunching the numbers.


I recently posted a second research article on A Fast Game, Where Do I Begin? Inspiration and intent in wargame design. I spent about four months on Where do I Begin; a little over three months conducting the survey and collating and analysing the data, and roughly five weeks writing it up, whenever I had a spare hour or two. There was some overlap with the analysis and the writing). The last two weeks I spent picking at the dataset like a buzzard with a carcass, teasing out a few more salient bits, but having blown my own deadline by nearly a month, I knew I had to let it go and put it out in the world.

Some people whose opinions I respect have commented positively about the article, which has been encouraging, but, like the first piece I researched and wrote up, The Value Proposition of Wargaming Awards - the Publishers' Perspective, I was left feeling that there was more to the story than I had managed to tease out.

This was by design: I prepared and sent out a two-question query letter because I didn’t want to discourage people from responding. Two questions felt more manageable for the time-poor; I had dropped a third question from the query letter so the effort of reply wouldn’t seem too demanding. I still think this was the right way to go. There’s no way of knowing for sure, but I suspect the returns may have been 20-30% lower than what I ultimately received.

Nearly all the feedback has been broadly positive from readers and participants alike. But one respondent raised something that had been in the back of my mind while I was writing up the analysis, only I hadn’t articulated it for myself so clearly.

“You write that you were astonished that over 75% of the designers who responded got their first effort into print. The flip side of that coin immediately occurred to me: do a large proportion of potential designers (or are you still considered a designer even if you're never published?) whose first submission is never printed give up?”

My first response to reading this wasn’t good. It felt like an attack; I can take criticism, but I was feeling a little raw from spending so much time on the project.

There are limits to what can be discovered for a short questionnaire, and by its nature, this sample group was made up of people who had gone once more into the breach with a prototype and a dream and had become published game designers. There was no way I could think of to isolate a population of failed one-time game designers who had given up after their first or first handful of rejections, except to approach random people on the street and ask them if they’d ever taken on such a Sisyphean task.

The writer went further:

‘No way to research this, of course, as by survey design and as a practical matter you have no data. [….] We'll never know, but perhaps even more remarkable is what percentage of rejected designers persevere and their later work does see the light of day?

This introduces a second factor. Everyone who responded was a published game designer. That was kind of the point of the article.

Surveys build their own limiters.

When I read through the email again, I realised what the writer was pointing out was very close to what was leaving me dissatisfied with what I’d written. I was only telling half of the story. And I hadn’t even tried to acknowledge there was more to it than I’d presented. In my defence, this was one of the last sections I wrote, the night before I posted the piece. I was tired and by then, probably not at my best, and I really wanted to get it done and up.

I wrote back, thanking the respondent for their thoughtful rebuttal. I said they were right – that I should have spent some time looking at the inverse take, that for every three designers who get their first offering into print, there’s another one who has to try again, push harder, and believe in themselves in their games that much more. In the end I thanked them for taking me to task, that it meant somebody was taking what I did seriously. And I meant it. I’m happy to say, we’re good.

Still, there must be people who create a game, maybe play it with friends or take it to a convention, maybe get some positive feedback, but never take the next step. Or they shop their prototype to a publisher or two, only to be told it doesn’t fit the company’s profile or customer base or some such and lose heart. Why should I care about people who never get past those first disappointments? Maybe I see something of myself in them.


What we're going to do about it

Anyway, here at A Fast Game, we’re about solutions. We’re also about snark and bawd, but mostly we’re about being positive and encouraging and uplifting. We talk about the games we love, and let others sing the praises – or not – of those we meet with indifference. In that spirit, we’ll be introducing a new semi-regular column, hopefully in the next month or so, that might help encourage the next round of new designers.

I’ve been kicking around an idea for another feature that I was going to pursue sometime next year, when things settle down a little more in my outside of wargaming life. Instead, I’m now rethinking the project. Rather than presenting it as another Big Project, I want to break it down into bite-sized morsels, posting a around one a month. I don’t want to say to much before I have something to present – that would be telling, and there are a few details to iron out – but I think it will make for interesting reading, and may even encourage those who got just so far but gave up to dust off their prototypes and take them to a convention or something, get them in front of some people.

Watch this space.

 

 


Tuesday, 10 November 2026

Blog Note: A Fast Game’s position on AI generated content

 


A non-AI-generated artist’s (me) impression of the writer (also me) winning the board
wargaming lottery – so, obviously a work of fiction (Thanks to MS Paint for the assist).


There’s a discussion in historical gaming circles that has become wildly divisive, even more so than “Is Twilight Struggle a wargame?” It revolves around the use of Generative Artificial Intelligence (or GAI* – if that’s not the accepted acronym, it damn well should be). It started off being about the use of GAI in game development and production, first more generally in the family boardgame and Euro space, then more recently in our shared wargame realm, with Compass Games going with an AI-generated cover illustration for one of their recent releases.†

As it has become easier to access and use GAI for image creation, the discussion has spread to “content creators” (like your humble correspondent).

Media impresario and friend of the blog, Jerry James, AKA Cardboard Commander, has been taking some flak over his use of GAI to create promo cards for his YouTube presentations. He has also stated he sometimes uses an AI program to tidy up his prose. He is not the only one who does this; Perigee uses AI for the title cards of his channel as well (if you don’t know his work, check it out here – he’ doing some really interesting stuff that’s well worth your time and bandwidth).

Personally, I don’t have a problem with this. Most non-wargaming channels I follow also use GAI in their presentations, mostly for title-cards, but some use it for creation of graphs and charts. I confess, I’m not immune to the car-crash allure of some AI-animated short stories on YouTube as well. I certainly don’t judge anyone who uses AI to add a little colour to their presentations.

I won’t be generating my own pictures with GAI (or with pencil and paper for that matter). I’m not being judgmental; I really just don’t like the ascetic. Some people do, or can live with it, and the algorithm seems to lap it up, so more power to ya. I’m not going to stop watching Jerry’s or anyone else’s videos over something like that. I’m just opting out from the visual stuff.


I am THIS old. My first computer was a borrowed IMB 5150, which I used to write all
of my essays in my first year at university. At the start of second year I bought a
bargain-bin PC with a 486-25 processor. Not really a digital native.


A Fast Game and AI

I don’t use generative AI for illustrations, and I can’t imagine a time where I would need to do so. I enjoy the hours and hours of tedious searching along the dark alleyways and virtual flea-markets of the Internet looking for that perfect photo or painting that hasn’t yet been stolen and shoved behind a licensing pay-wall by Alamy or Shutterstock. I have used AI-driven image-search tools a couple of times to help identify a particular painting used on a game box, but that tends to be a last gasp choice and has actually helped less than 50% of the time.

I do use some AI-driven tools; if you write with a computer, it’s pretty much unavoidable. I write nearly all my posts in a Word.doc file called “Working” with today’s date after it when I remember to save a copy. I’ve used the same file (or clones of it) for about three years now (to keep everything together), and except for a couple of longer pieces that warranted their own file, everything started there. Using Word, I lean on the Spellcheck and Thesaurus functions, which are both AI-driven now (and are generally better tools for that). I don’t use the Autocorrect because it still insists everything should sound like an earnings report, but that’s a personal gripe; I don’t judge anyone who wants Word’s second opinion, or Grammarly’s or whichever your editorial assistant of choice may be.

I started wanting to make a statement about AI tools, and ended with a work-practice confessional. Not where I thought this was headed, but there you go. It’s hard to rage against the machine then the machines are just so darn helpful (I’m not talking about you, HP printer). 

AI is just a tool. Like a really expensive, thirsty wrench. So, if you're angry about AI slop, or billionaires, or somebody trying to pass off a program's work as their own, try to keep your anger directed at source of the problem, not some guy just trying to get his efforts noticed. 

 

* We need to normalise the use of GAI in reference to generative AI, if only – in true Beastie Boys fashion – to point at truly terrible AI slop and say “That’s GAI.”

† I’m not going to throw shade here. If the designer and publisher agree to go with AI art, I’m not going to jump on a soap-box and call for their resignations or something. Compass and designer Raymond Fiore have been quite up front about it, so no deceit or burying the lead here. If you’re curious, you could do worse than checking out Ray’s unboxing of his own game on his YouTube channel, 6 Actual (in my opinion, another one worth your time).



Saturday, 7 November 2026

Stripped Down for Parts: PQ-17: Arctic Naval Operations 1941-1943

 




Note: Here I am unboxing a decade-plus old game, checking to see if the designer snuck some gold brick in while nobody was looking. If you have no idea what I’m talking about, go watch Cardboard Commander’s recent video on his YouTube channel.

 

I have in my study a literal pile of games I have been meaning to write up unboxing posts. I’m hoping to clear some of that backlog between now and the Christmas break, but something arrived today that I knew would be jumping the queue when it arrived.

A copy of PQ-17: Arctic Naval Operations 1941-1943 (GMT Games, 2009) showed up at an interstate game store that specialises in estate collections. This is one of those classic GMT games that has a dedicated following – popular enough for an expansion pack, Norway 1940 (GMT Games, 2022) just a few years ago, but it’s unlikely to see a reprint in the near to mid-term. Naval games are a bit of a niche market within the niche market of wargaming. I’ve been pulling my horns in – or at lease trying to resist temptation when it presents itself – but PQ-17 seems to be a bit of a Flying Dutchman on the second-hand market, so I had to set fiscal prudence aside this one time.*

PQ-17 simulates the action in the Norwegian and Barents Seas in 1941 through 1943, when supply convoys carried much needed fuel and materiel from the United Kingdom and Iceland to the Northern ports of the Soviet Union under the Anglo-Soviet Agreement and eventually the United States’ Lend-Lease program. The game’s title comes from the most ill-starred of these convoys, of which only eleven of the thirty-five ships that set out from Iceland made it all the way to the Russian ports of Matochkin, Murmansk and Arkhangelsk.

Box top.

PQ-17 came out in 2009, and its appearance fits the period. The cover is classic Rodger McGowan, but it’s a little different from many of his more famous box work. The box-top background is a solid Imperial Blue, and It features an offset illustration (worked up from a photo) of the view over the stern of a British destroyer among a convoy, with a couple of German bombers added for flavour. The green of the choppy Arctic waters and the Lavenders and violets of the scudding clouds and darkening horizon are perfectly framed by the blue of the background. To thew left of the illustration if the title, piled upon itself like cargo that has shifted during evasive manoeuvres, and in the bottom left corner the red GMT logo also pops against the blue.† This might be my new favourite McGowan cover illustration.

Box back. 

The box-back has a foundation of Uranian Blue and features a full representation of the game map at the top, and a written description of the game play, highlighting some of the features of the game. The lower right quadrant is given over to a pale butter-coloured box presenting the Game Contents, Scale, "Game Meter" and Credits, as well as some sample counters presented in their actual size. We’ll be going over all the contents, so I’ll leave off that for now. The Scale tells us that each turn represents twelve hours on the ocean (two turns to a full twenty-four hour day, though this means less when travelling in hazardous waters in either perpetual day or night for much of the year), and each hex represents an area 96 nautical miles across. The game’s Complexity is rated at a five out of nine, while Solitaire Suitability is a one out of nine, though there is evidence in the BGG discussion of the game of brave souls managing familiarisation games solo, using concocted randomisation techniques to conduct the Axis search parts, reportedly with some success.

 

The Rule Book.

The rulebook is presented in black and white, on a heavier matte paper (feels like about 90gsm or so), well laid-out and profusely illustrated (both functionally and decoratively (and runs to thirty-two pages. The actual rules come to just twenty-four pages. The remaining pages are taken up with a Cover/Table of Content, three pages devoted to the game components, a through two-page Index, and an Extended Sequence of Play on the back cover.

Rule Book (sample spread). The second Edition rulebook coming with the Norway 1940
expansion will be colour throughout.


God is in the details. Both the Rule Book and the Play Book feature an Extended
Sequence of Play on their back covers. That is a nice surprise. 

Comments on BGG suggest some folks have had difficulties with the original rulebook. GMT and designer Chris Janiec have since released an expansion for PQ-17, Norway, 1940 (GMT Games, 2022) which includes a rewritten and expanded Second Edition rulebook. The store from which I bought PQ-17 also had a copy of Norway, 1940, but my budget wouldn’t quite stretch to that as well. But GMT has made a copy of the second edition rules available as a pdf on the PQ-17 product page. Norway, 1940 looks like something I will want to grab sometime though, and not merely for a sense of completion.

The Play Book. Nine historical scenarios, one full-year campaign, and a random
scenario generator; it's the gift that keeps on giving. 

The Play Book shares the same material qualities as the Rule Book, and also comes in at thirty-two pages. The scenario content runs to sixteen pages, including a Scenario Format guide and a couple of optional rules. Also included are a similar cover page with Table of Contents, a nine-page Extended Example of Play, five pages of Designer’s Notes, a partial bibliography, and a duplicate of Extended Sequence of Play featured on the last page of the Rule Book.

PlayBook (sample spread).

PQ-17 is an Operational-level game, and the first nine scenarios cover historical operations covering actual convoys or events in hindsight referred to as battles. The tenth scenario is a toolkit for developing random scenarios, thus extending the game’s replayability, and the final scenario is a Campaign game running from the beginning of March, 1942 until the first of January 1943.

Scenarios 11 & 12. I haven't investigated this, but I don't know if this sheet came with the
original set or if it was added later. Drop me ka note if you can shed some light on this.


Additional scenario (with a pair of extra counters), published in C3i.

As mentioned earlier, I bought this copy second-hand, presumably from a deceased estate. While the previous owner never actually got to play this copy of PQ-17, we can deduce that they had a bit of a completist streak; included in this set was a cardstock addition that isn’t listed on the manifest, adding two more scenarios to the set, plus another scenario and two counters from an issue of C3i magazine. At this point, I don’t think I’ll ever get to play the full year campaign game, but to play the original nine historical scenarios from the Play Book plus the three bonus scenarios may just be an achievable goal.

Wooden blocks. These are about the size of Commands & Colors infantry blocks.

Sticker sheet.

PQ-17 comes with a bag of blocks in blue and light grey, 58 in all, and a sheet of stickers to apply to said blocks. The blocks are single-sided, and do the work of representing where forces are, or where they might be, on the map. Air assets and various makers (all counters, which we’ll get to next) are also used on the map.

While simple and functional the map is really quite attractive. Well, I think so. Along with the play or manoeuvre area, it offers a key to the map and other game elements, tracks for noting prevailing weather and ice conditions, as well as holding boxes for the ports and airbases dotted around the various coastlines.

Counter Sheet 1 - Allied naval assets.

Counter sheet 2 - Allied and Axis (grey) naval assets.

The game boasts four counter sheets, two of 1” square ship, flotilla, and convoy counters, and two sheets of round counters designating air assets, as well as a half-sheet of half inch markers. The large ship markers don’t appear on the map, but are rather grouped into Task Forces and Convoy groups. The ship and flotilla counters have numbers marked on one or more of their edges and rotate like a Columbia Games’ unit block to indicate relative damage taken and the sea-worthiness of the vessel. The one-inch counters feel more like tiles, but they should; each one represents an artificial island populated by brave fools facing death every time they set out of port.

Counter sheet 3 - Allied air assets.

Counter sheet 4 - Axis and Soviet air assets.

Counter sheet 5 - half-inch markers.

The counters are printed on white-core cardstock, a little thinner than you would expect to see in a current GMT game. I don’t personally have an issue with the lighter counters. They should still be thick enough to manipulate without too much difficulty, and they will clip up nicely (and the air assets won’t need clipping at all).

 

The PQ-17 map. As usual apologies for the poor photography on display in this post.
This picture doesn't do justice to the elegance of functionality
inherent in this game map.

The game map covers the area of operations – the Norwegian and Barents Seas – and their bordering coastlines, along with the ports and airbases crucial to play. The hexes are big, representing 98 nautical miles side to side. They are big enough to accommodate multiple representative blocks. The map is where the operational part of the game takes place. In their turn, each side moves their assets and attempts to successfully search or evade the opposing forces. When combat does occur, it may be dealt with in different ways. Air to surface or submarine attacks are abstracted to a set of die-rolls. Surface actions between ships are played out on a battle-board (which we will also get to in due course).


The Force Displays are where a lot of the bookkeeping happens. Well, to be fair, the introduction of the Force Displays and maritime asset counters eases the substantial bookkeeping you would otherwise need to do to run the game (compared to, say, Flying Colors (GMT Games. 2003)). These provide a visual display for water-borne assets with which you can group the ships together and represent a group with a single block on a wide expanse of ocean.

The force displays, battle board, and PACs are all printed on the same weight cardstock, which in turn is comparable to most GMT games. They are all sturdy enough for consistent referral at the table but light enough to keep the overall box-weight lower for freight considerations.

The game comes with a whole pad of Planning Sheets. These look more daunting
than they actually are.

Operations for each side are plotted out on a Planning Sheet at the beginning of a scenario. This is also where the rest of the bookkeeping is done; the Planning Sheet helps the players record the composition of their Task Forces, track their Command Point (CP) spend, Victory Points gained and interceptors lost through the course of play. The game comes with a pad of these sheets, each double-sided. I, of course, will insist on keeping the pad pristine and run off copies of the sheet top use instead. Don't judge me.

The Battle Board, where the operational game gets tactical.

PQ-17 uses a battle board for surface engagements – air bombardment and Sub/wolfpack attacks are handled more abstractly. The battle board is a concept born out of The War at Sea (Jedko Games, 1975), and used in a bunch of naval wargames since, from Holdfast: Pacific (Worthington Publishing, 2017) to Atlantic Chase (GMT Games, 2021). This simplifies the action but still builds in options for some basic manoeuvres.

The outer panels of the Axis Player Aid Card (PAC).

The game comes with two bi-fold (11” by 17”) Player Aid Cards, marked individually as the Allied and Axis PACs. The outer panels of the PACs are identical (except for their identification) and offer all the tables you’ll need for every aspect of combat between ships, Submarines and aircraft. 

Inside the Axis PAC. The two PACs are nearly identical, but for the Order of Battle
(of course) and the Random Events Table. Bad things happen (sometimes uniquely)
to both sides.

The differences are inside the fold; the two PACs boast their own Campaign Orders of Battle (exclusively for the 1942 Campaign game), a Random Event Table exclusive to that faction, and a Special Conditions Chart (this is consulted after a die-roll during the Random Event Segment of each turn (the sea is a harsh mistress).

The Weather and Ice PACs, because it's not enough to have planes and subs chasing
 you, the whole environment is trying to sink your ships.

PQ-17 also brings a matching pair of Weather and Ice PACs. The front side shows the incredibly thorough Weather Table – results run from ≤1 to ≥20 over twelve columns for each month of the year – and a short explanatory table of Weather Effects. The verso presents a Unit (explanatory) Chart Ice Table and an Ice Effects explainer, a Reconnaissance Chart and a Variable Start Table.

Axis and Allied card decks.

Sample cards. Each deck comes with a Reminder covering the Reconnaissance
and Shadowing and the limitations of movement for Wolfpacks.

There are two 40-card decks that come with the game, one each for the Allied and German players. Cards are drawn when an enemy asset is searched for during the Reconnaissance Phase, and to check for possible damage to the player's own ships underway. This simulation is as much a fight against nature as it is the enemy.

 

The game comes with five d10s and a signed packing slip, an elegant gesture from
a more civilised age. Not pictured are the two rolls of baggies that came with
this copy. I don't know if every copy came with two rolls, but I'm sure
they'll come in handy.
  

PQ-17 comes in a standard two-inch box, with baggies and a set of five ten-sided dice (numbered 0-9) The dice are quite nice, but . The box is admittedly a little thin-panelled and the side-panels have bowed out a little bit – a common enough occurrence in this weight of cardboard. It still does the job, but it’s a reminder to be grateful for GMT’s improved box standards from the last maybe five or so years.

There’s quite a bit to the game in terms of contents, but it’s mostly light card-stock PACs and the paper map. I’d like to eventually get a Cube-4-Me storage set for this game. I checked, and yes, they do have a curated set of counter and card containers for PQ-17, which impressed me. I'm just concerned about whether everything from Norway 1040 will manage to pit into the box as well.

-----

This unboxing feels a little thin to me on detail compared to my usual unboxing efforts, where I try to convey a little more of how the parts interact and how the game will play out on the table, or at least how it’s meant to. Part of the reason for that is time - I’ve had this for a couple of weeks now, but I’ve and a few things on the go, so I haven’t had much time to get spend with the game. The expansion for PQ-17, Norway 1940, includes a Second Edition rule book (in glorious full-colour).^ Norway 1940 is now on its way to Casa Dyer as I write this, so at this point I may as well wait for that to read, instead of struggling with the “difficult” first edition. What do we say to fiscal prudence? Not today!


* Actually, I had to set it aside twice; I grabbed second game from the store on the same order. I told myself I was actually saving money on postage. The economics of self-deceit.

† While I was writing this up, I happened to notice the bottom edge panel. This end must have been the one showing on the previous owner’s shelf – there GMT logo has faded with sun-bleach to a very pale pink, but the Uranian Blue has stood up admirably.

^ Norway 1940 arrived just as I was marking this post up for publication. A replacement rulebook, an extra play book, two more sheets of counters (plus another half-sheet of half-inch markers, supplementary PACs and a campaign board for the land battle for Norway. The expansion brings three more scenarios to the table and a Norway Campaign game.

 

 

Monday, 26 October 2026

A Fast Take: limiting Command and Control in wargames - part 3

  

 

This will make more sense if you have read the first two parts first. You can find them here and here, respectively. If you haven’t read them yet, go do that. Thank come back and read this as well.


"I would rather have a general who was lucky than one who was good." - Napoleon Bonaparte
(Napoleon at Bay: the Campaign in France, 1814 (Avalon Hill, 1978);
picture courtesy of Tac Ope (BGG)). 

 

This is the final post in a three-part consideration of game designer Fernando Sola Ramos’s short essay entitled Mando y control en los wargames (Command and Control in wargames), which appeared in Josep Oliver’s excellent blog, El desafío de las Águilas. If you haven’t already, head over to las Águilas read Sr. Ramos’s article (linked above); I'll wait. Since I began this consideration series, las Águilas has featured a handful of other short articles by Sr. Ramos examining various aspects of how wargames try to simulate the realities of armed conflict. All of these are well worth your time.

In this final part, I’ll look at the last two of six methods Sr Ramos identified as used in wargames to mimic the limits of Command in Control (refer back to part 1 for the complete listing). The two models we'll look at here (along with Sr. Ramos's own exemplary wargame examples) are:

- Leadership-distance chain of command (Great Battles of the American Civil War series)


 - Limiting attacks to command formations (i.e. disallowing or limiting ad hoc formations). Sr Ramos didn’t single out a particular example here, but visually represented Mark Simonitch’s “ZoC-Bond” family of games.

In Parts 1 & 2, I looked at the first four models in the list, adding a couple of examples of my own. Here I’m looking at the last two model Sr. Ramos listed. I’m considering just one game for each. Some people might eve argue over whether the games I’ve chosen to represent each model. Many of the games I’ve looked at would sit just as comfortably under at least one more of the defined models.

 

Leadership-distance chain of command


Redvers’ Reverse: the Battle of Colenso, 1899 (Legion Wargames, 2016) is my pick for a game that effectively represents the tribulations of Command in Control over distance. It’s a solitaire game, so it won’t appeal to everyone, and like all good solitaire games, it’s bloody difficult to successfully meet all the victory conditions. It portrays the battle of Colenso, fought in December 1899, during the Second Anglo-Boer War. General Redvers Buller had been selected to command the British Army of Natal but had a mixed bag of commanders under him; some were exhibited apprehension in the face of the enemy, some were unduly reckless, and more then one believed he should have been in command instead of Buller. The board is an area movement map, and the units are brigade-level.

A den of vipers: Buller weighing up his options before the balloon goes up.

The game elegantly captures the difficulty of leading an ad hoc force that to a degree resents being led, or downright refuses to be. The first hurdle is the delivery of orders. The game allows a limited number of Command Points. These are used to place Objective markers unique to each ordered brigade on the board.

With distance comes uncertainty. Depending on how far a brigade is from Buller's HQ, an order may be delivered in the same turn, or the next, or two turns hence. Or not at all - with distance comes the possibility of the messenger getting lost or being unable to find the brigade commander for whom the order was intended.

The Send Orders and Receive Orders Tables from the Redvers' Reverse PAC,
bringing a little more uncertainty to your well-laid plans.

The next phase is where you see the initial outcome of your orders. Each Brigade Leader has a rating based on their historical performance. A leader may be Aggressive, Good, or Cautious. The player must roll for each unit ordered, and depending on the quality of the Brigade commander, they will either ignore the order, execute it as best as they can interpret (moving by the shortest possible path to the Objective), or Charge to the Guns (make their way to the closest Boer troops). In my experience it is not unknown for a brigade saddled with a Cautious commander to ignore one order in two or more, even as their more aggressively led brethren are being mowed down by Boer fire from the heights.

A little chaos - British forces struggle for find a way across the river.

This probably sounds to some like an awful way to run a battle. It is, but it also reflects the manner of difficulties the beleaguered Buller faced at Colenso.

 

Attacks limited to command formations

Dunkirk: France, 1940 (Worthington Games, 2018) presents an operational level situation at a minute scale. The game captures the whole of the German advance on France and the Low Countries. The game is a study in reductionism, covering the initial Western campaign on a twelve-by-twelve hex-grid and in a mere six turns.

The author's much-loved copy of Dunkirk.

The opposing forces are represented by blocks (each representing roughly a corps), and grouped into armies, except the German forces who are grouped into Army Groups A and B, each with its own HQ block. Each side also has a GHQ block which remains off-board, but records the extra orders that can be allocated during turns. Activation is by a chit-pull mechanism, or more accurately a block pull – each Allied formation has its own draw token, while the two Axis army groups have two each. The Axis player gets to keep one draw block in hand (for either Army Group) to kick off the hostilities, and he uses the double orders for both formations over the first two turns (there’s an optional rule to allow use of the extra orders for the third or even fourth turn, should it be deemed the Germans need a little extra help).

In their turn, a formation’s units can move and/or attack; Infantry units can move two hexes (subject to terrain conditions), and mechanised units up to three. Up to two units can occupy the same hex at the same time.

Dunkirk set up for play.

But this is where the Formation limitations kick in. It starts with set up; various hexes are marked as beginning locations for each formation. This means that they begin within command distance of the formation HQ. At the formation’s Activation, all the units in the formation must be within the Command radius of the formation’s HQ or suffer penalties: an out-of-command unit’s movement is reduced by one, it cannot move to engage in combat, and its fighting strength is severely impeded.

The Command distance for all of the Allied formations is two hexes, for the German formations it’s three hexes (to reflect the superior command discipline and forward planning of the invaders). It is possible for units from two allied formations to share a hex, but they must fight independently (and conversely must be attacked separately by enemy forces).

Army Group A's surprise attack from the "inpenertrable" Ardennes.

The whole campaign a tricky manoeuvre operation in a claustrophobic environment, and under severe time constraints. Forward planning becomes crucial to ensure each side’s ability to effectively attack or defend. It’s here that the importance of command distance shines: out-of-command units become sitting ducks, unable to prosecute battle, and ill-equipped to defend themselves, but in a crowded battlefield, it can become difficult to maintain command cohesion. While Dunkirk plays out quickly, it is always an intense and challenging game.

 

-----

 

So, that covers my quick and dirty look at Fernando Sola Ramos’s six Command-in-Control models in wargames. I’m very grateful to Sr. Ramos and Josep Oliver for the opportunity to respond to the article (just a reminder that there’s a link to the original post at the top of this piece). As I said in the first part, it’s something that I’ve been wanting to engage with on A Fast Game for a while, and Sr. Ramos’s piece offered an excellent entry framework. This is a concept that I’m deeply interested in and that I expect we’ll revisit in the future.

 

 

Overthinking it: on the Limitations of Research; or, crashing the gate

  Crunching the numbers. I recently posted a second research article on A Fast Game, Where Do I Begin? Inspiration and intent in wargame des...