Sunday, 22 November 2026

Lessons learned - Game designers on designing games (and other diversions) - Part 1

  

 

 

Coach Wooden knew something about learning and sharing.

I don't think about whether people will remember me or not. [….] I've learned a lot. I've taught people a thing or two. That's what's important.

— Julia Child

 

Welcome to a new, ongoing column for A Fast Game. After the last long-form piece presented on the blog, I thought I hadn't managed to get the whole of the story. That piece was based on a survey of published designers, asking them about their first game designs. I was curious about what the designers would do differently if they had the opportunity to do it over again. I actually mentioned something like this in my correspondence with Paul Hellyer, who offered a pretty honest appraisal (you can read it here, about half-way through). I think the work was worthwhile overall, I regretted not asking that third question of all the respondents.

So, I’ve started going back to the list, pestering people with two more questions:

Q1: What's the one thing you would tell yourself if you could go back to when you first started designing games?

Q2: What do you know now that you wish you had known back then?

I’ve been asking my correspondents to answer one or the other question as they would prefer, but many have been returning answers to both.

 A mark of our shared hobby is how willing wargamers are to help their fellows, giving of their own time and experience to teach a new game or clarify a sticky rule. That same generosity of spirit is what lets me offer this first instalment of what will hopefully become a monthly staple of A Fast Game.

My initial thinking here was to provide an ongoing source of advice and encouragement to people just starting out in game design. My justification for this column is by belief that any opportunity to learn or to offer instruction should be grabbed with both hands. Everyone’s experience is different, and milage may vary, but it’s my hope that the reader will be able to find something here to take away. Here you’ll get the unvarnished thoughts of game designers on how the sausage is made. This should be fun.

I want to thank Greg Smith and Nicola Contardi for their encouragement pursuing this project, and thanks to all the folks who have responded thus far (if you don’t see your contribution here, it will be in next month’s column). And a special thank-you to friend of the blog Brian Train, who I went to for advice on which question would be better to ask, replied that they were both good, and returned convincing answers for each.

 

-----

 

Brian Train – designer, China’s War, District Commander series; publisher, BTR Games

What's the one thing you would tell yourself if you could go back to when you first started designing games?

I don't think I would tell myself much, at least not at first... I would just look at what I was doing and shake my head. Then I would tell myself that really, it does get easier and that I would really find my own voice one day.

 

What do you know now that you wish you had known back then?

How to write rules. It's an exacting form of technical writing and learning how was an apprenticeship, certainly. in 2021 I did a new edition of Civil Power (Conflict Simulations Ltd, 2021), designed in 1991 and one of my first games - rewriting the rules took almost as much time as simply starting over from scratch.

 

-----

 

Gregory M. Smith – designer, The Hunters: German U-Boats at War, 1939-43, Western Front Ace: The Great War in the Air, 1916-1918

What's the one thing you would tell yourself if you could go back to when you first started designing games?

Have a thick skin. I mean, really thick. Especially with the advent of social media, you'll need it to progress without despairing.  The point being, every game, no matter how good, amazing, clever, and well-designed, will have people who just flat out hate it. Guaranteed. Which is fine, as no game will appeal to everyone.  Typically, they also unfortunately fall into what I call the "vocal minority." 95% of people might really like your game but the other 5% will be responsible for most of the traffic about it, it seems. So, you've just got to realize everybody's got an opinion and roll with it. State your side, be honest, but also realize some issues are simply a matter of opinion. The issues that are factual need to be resolved. But don't let the haters win.

 

British Tank Ace - the most recently published volume in the Tank Ace series
from Compass Games.

What do you know now that you wish you had known back then?

I think my biggest learning lesson, that I wish I had known at the start, is that testing is KEY. Not just personally, but also with outsiders. Having played SPI games in the 1970s, I should have focused on this, but didn't. What I mean by that statement is I played plenty of games 50 years ago, thinking to myself at times, "did these guys even play this to the end???" I should have remembered that.  I have always tested my games but probably not all of them enough, and I've definitely noticed the games where I did a TON of testing turned out much better than the ones where it was just a few runs. It's not just catching the simple errors and typos, but also for play balance and sometimes for improvement in mechanics. It sounds like common sense, but I think it sometimes, in the haste to get done, it is overlooked, not just by myself but by others.

 

-----

 

Didier Rouy – designer, the Vive l’Empereur! series (including La Bataille de Wagram (coming soon from Legion Wargames).

What's the one thing you would tell yourself if you could go back to when you first started designing games?

Don't hesitate to copy things from other games or systems if they are good. In my case that was the shape of the counters, rectangular instead of square, coming from the Yaquinto games and really good solutions. I adapted them to line/columns. I probably stole a few more ideas and created a lot many more.

 

What do you know now that you wish you had known back then?

That, I don't really know. Maybe the difficulty of actually publishing games, I started as a designer, then moved to editor with Pratzen, now back to designer, which is what I enjoy most.

 

-----

 

John Gorkowski – Designer, Breaking the Chains: War in the South China Sea, In the Trenches series, Balance of Powers

What's the one thing you would tell yourself if you could go back to when you first started designing games?

Make time right now to meet your heroes-of-the-hobby before they are gone.  I started fiddling with wargame design in my mid 30s, circa 2005.  At that time, many of the people who had pioneered the RPGs that so inspired me as a teen were still around.  You could meet them at conventions.  Like so many other 30-somethings, I was too busy with daily life to carve out time for those events. 

Then Gary Gygax died.  He was the first of several Grognards who would pass starting in 2008.  Their departures triggered a raft of articles about hobby history.  As I read through them, I found many shared interests - Gary started as a wargamer - that left me wondering what it might have been like to actually talk to them.  The passing of Tom Moldvay was another loss that I felt more deeply over time.  Having first played his games as a teen, I did not at that time fully appreciate what he had accomplished.  Only after rereading his material as an adult, did I comprehend the full extent of his creativity and contributions to the hobby.  I'm sorry to have missed that window of opportunity to actually talk to those hobby greats.

So, track down your heroes while they are still here.

 

-----

 

Salvatore Vasta – designer, Unconditional Surrender: World War II in Europe

What's the one thing you would tell yourself if you could go back to when you first started designing games?

It is much more time consuming then you'd imagine. Basically, you can play games, or you can design them. Doing both at the same time is not very likely so decide what you'd rather do more of and stick to it.

 

At time of posting, the third edition of Sal Vasta's Unconditional Surrender is available
for preorder at the GMT website.

What do you know now that you wish you had known back then?

If the game is large or complex, no matter how much time you spend on development, mistakes or play balance issues will make into the final product. There is only so much a designer, developer, and playtesters can do. They can't view the product in the same way that hundreds or thousands of players will view it. That's why software is often released with bugs or less than planned functionality. The feedback from all those gamers helps to reveal what your small design group never saw.

 

-----

 

Mark McLaughlin – designer, War and Peace, Mr. Lincoln's War

Hmmmm... oddly enough, my answer to both is 'nothing'... seriously, I have had such good fortune about being at the right place at the right time with the right idea and the right editors that there is nothing I would do differently.  I know that might sound prideful, but the luck of the Irish has been very good to me... and it still is  (I have two games on pre-order with GMT [The Napoleonic Wars: 25th Anniversary Edition (GMT Games, 2008) and Ancient Civilizations of East Asia (GMT Games, ~2027)], one with Compass [Viceroys, Task Force Games, 1986)] one with Legion [Hannibal's Revenge, (Legion Wargames, ~2027)] and Compass is working on redoing another of my old games... plus Avalon Digital is considering turning my Mr. Lincoln's War (which Compass redid earlier this year) into a computer version (as they did with War and Peace which came out as Napoleon's Eagles... and that game is getting new content before the end of the year.

Seriously, the guardian angel of wargame designers surely sits on my shoulder.

 

-----

 

Nicola Contardi – designer, All Is Lost Save Honour, El Gran Capitán (Campaigns of the Italian Wars 1494-1530, Vols 1 & 2)

What's the one thing you would tell yourself if you could go back to when you first started designing games?

I would say to myself: "You are going to design the games that you love to appear in the market. It is correct, but do not expect that this will necessarily attract interest in other people. This is how things go."

 

What do you know now that you wish you had known back then?

Very few people really test your design against history. Most of them will like smooth and entertaining mechanics more. This is how things go.

 

-----

 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Lessons learned - Game designers on designing games (and other diversions) - Part 1

        C oach Wooden knew something about learning and sharing. I don't think about whether people will remember me or not. [….] ...